When a roof reaches the end of its useful life, or damage from storms makes winter seem closer than expected, the right roofing company can turn crisis into comfort. It’s estimated that the average residential roof lasts 20 to 30 years depending on materials and maintenance—a reminder that expert installation and quality maintenance matter. The Best of the Best recognizes local firms that bring skilled workmanship, timely service and deep local experience to Frederick-area homeowners. Below are five noteworthy finalists in that category—each bringing a distinct story and service approach.
PJ’s Roofing is a family-owned operation based in Frederick that began when founder Paul “PJ” Nicholson started with a truck, two helpers and a strong work ethic. Their estimators are tradesmen rather than salesmen, and the team is licensed in Maryland and Pennsylvania. They handle everything from large replacements to tricky repairs, and they promote metal roofing, slate, copper, and architectural shingles—meaning they serve both historic homes and modern builds alike. The company still keeps its roots in Frederick even as it has grown.
A&S Construction identifies itself as a woman- and minority-owned business focused on roofing, gutters, siding, window and patio services. It serves Frederick and nearby areas and emphasizes a client-experience approach—appointment confirmations, foreman follow-through and detailed visuals. If you want that extra layer of communication and oversight, this firm highlights those touches.
BulletpROOF Exteriors, based in Thurmont, advertises over 50 years of combined experience in its team and provides 24/7 emergency roofing service. They offer free consultations, metal roofing options and warranties including product and workmanship. They’re GAF Master Elite® certified and promote high standards of installation and materials. For homeowners who value readiness for storm damage and advanced certifications, BulletpROOF presents itself as a strong option.
M&J Exteriors in Frederick frames itself as a full-service contractor covering roofing, gutters and exterior systems. The family-owned business is committed to competitive pricing plus full project management. They work with manufacturer brands such as CertainTeed, GAF, Owens Corning and Firestone, and emphasize both new installation and repairs—as well as gutter systems.
Topper Construction is a long-standing Frederick-based exterior contractor, founded in 1988, that has installed roofing and siding on tens of thousands of homes across a five-state region. Topper has a large window of experience—since 1988—serving as both homeowners and builders. With multiple certification badges, they position themselves as heavy-duty but still available to local residential jobs. If scale and licensing depth matter to you, Topper brings that capacity.
Thanks, ChatGPT.